Skip to content
No results
  • Academy
  • My Courses
  • Products
    • RBT Practice Exam
    • Books
  • Resources
    • Collections
  • Tools
    • Behavioral Functions Assessment Tool (B-FAT)
  • About Us
    • Contact
  • My Cart
  • Login
Accessible Behavior
  • Academy
  • My Courses
  • Products
    • RBT Practice Exam
    • Books
  • Resources
    • Collections
  • Tools
    • Behavioral Functions Assessment Tool (B-FAT)
  • About Us
    • Contact
  • My Cart
  • Login
Accessible Behavior
A close-up of an adult and older teenager speaking loudly during a tense hallway disagreement, showing a parent-child power struggle without physical contact.

In a power struggle, the child always wins

article
Adult Communication & InteractionBehaviorsConcepts & IdeasSocial Interaction & Relationships
BCBAsParents & CaregiversRBTsTeachers & Educators

A power struggle begins when an adult is pulled into an angry back-and-forth with a child. This article explains how steady authority, patience, listening, and choice can replace coercion.

  • Dr. Peter Beddow, BCBA-DDr. Peter Beddow, BCBA-D
  • 2026-11-05
Share this page

Leer en español: En una lucha de poder, el niño siempre gana

Power struggles are among the most common habits that adults develop when working with children in general, not just children with serious behavior problems.

A power struggle happens when an adult demands that a child engage in a specific behavior or follow a specific direction, and the child refuses. The adult pushes, and the child keeps refusing. Then the adult either raises the intensity of the demand or begins to add punishment on top of it.

Power struggles can look like arguments. They can look like a back and forth between the adult and the child, where the child keeps refusing and the adult keeps demanding. Neither side makes progress, and the relationship becomes adversarial.

The purpose of this article is to declare plainly that in a power struggle between an adult and a child, the child always wins.

That is my framing, and I mean it as a way of seeing what is really happening. It is not a measured research result. No study has scored these contests and found that children come out ahead every time. But I say it with confidence, because of what a power struggle shows about the adult.

Why the child wins

The child always wins because when an adult engages in a power struggle with a child, it is a sign that the child has gained control over the adult's behavior.

Think about what is happening in the moment. The child refuses. The adult raises the voice. The child refuses again. The adult adds a threat. The child's refusal is now deciding what the adult says and does next. The adult has stopped leading and started reacting.

A power struggle always represents the adult failing to recognize his or her own authority and influence. It also represents the adult forgetting that there are resources other than arguing and coercion for making progress and restoring the relationship.

This is why I like to say to adults: I never argue with the child.

Arguing puts me on the same level as the child. It turns a direction into a debate. Once I am debating, I have already given up the thing that made my direction worth following in the first place.

What the research says about these patterns

Researchers have studied interactions like these for a long time, and their work helps explain why power struggles are so easy to fall into and so hard to get out of.

Hoffman's 1960 article in Child Development examined power assertion by parents and its impact on children. Decades later, Bugental and Happaney (2000) described parent-child interaction as a power contest. That line of work treats these exchanges as a two-way pattern, where adult and child each affect the other.

Coercion theory makes a similar point. As Moed (2024) summarizes it, coercion theory describes how parents and children mutually "train" each other over time in ways that increase the likelihood of children's aggression and decrease parents' control over that aggression. Moed proposes extending the theory to include the emotions parents experience as part of what keeps coercive cycles going. A 2004 review in this area proposed an early childhood coercion model focused on clarifying parent-child reciprocities in the early years.

This research does not prove that "the child always wins." What it does support is the idea that these exchanges are reciprocal, that they build over time, and that adult reactions are part of the cycle. That fits closely with what I am saying: when the adult gets pulled into the fight, the child's behavior is shaping the adult's behavior.

How power struggles start: your yes and your no

Power struggles often arise after adults have shown, over time, that they do not always keep their promises. Their yes is not always yes, and their no is not always no.

So I say to adults: your yes is not always yes, and your no is not always no. And children notice.

Now when an adult gives a direction, the child has evidence from history that the adult may not follow through. The adult may not have the emotional fortitude to follow through. The adult may not remember why the direction was given in the first place. And when the child's behavior escalates, the adult looks for a way out of the escalation.

That moment of escalation is actually an opportunity. It is the chance to show the child that you mean what you say, that you don't use words lightly, and that the words you use have meaning.

If the adult backs down when the child gets louder, the child learns that getting louder works. If the adult gets louder in return, the child learns that the adult can be pulled into a fight. Either way, the child has gained control over what the adult does.

The answer is to be an adult whose words are reliable. When I say something, I follow through. When I give a direction, I have thought about it first, I remember why I gave it, and I am prepared to stand by it calmly.

"I can wait"

My favorite phrase to use with a child, instead of engaging in a power struggle, is I can wait.

I don't have to coerce a child to do what the child is supposed to do. The child is always free to refuse an adult's direction. I cannot force a child to follow my direction.

I might be able to physically move the child's body through the motions of following a direction. But if the child's will was not involved, all I have done is create a punishing incident that weakens the relationship between me and that child.

The only real compliance is when a child chooses to follow an adult's direction. Forced compliance is not compliant.

In our work, we do not use the word compliance. We also don't use the word defiance. Those words frame the child as either obeying or rebelling, and they frame the adult's job as getting obedience. That is the wrong picture. Children are free to choose.

We do want children to do what they're supposed to do. But we don't believe it is necessary to coerce them.

What we do instead

Instead of coercion, we provide abundant opportunities throughout each day for children to enjoy rich, exciting, and interesting things. They do fun things and have interesting activities. They sing songs, play games, create things, learn things, do new things, and spend time with friends. Funny things happen.

When a child is not doing what they're supposed to do, those things are simply not available.

We don't take them away as though the child has done something to make us angry. There is no punishment being handed out. We just make participation depend on the child listening to the voices of the adults.

And we are always careful not to demand or require children to do things that are harmful to them or that cause them suffering. We simply ask them to stay with us and to try to engage in the activities we have prepared for them.

So when a child chooses not to, or refuses, we can say, "I can wait."

While we wait, the child sits in the situation they have created for themselves. That situation is less interesting, less exciting, less colorful, less vibrant, and has less relationship in it. The child can sit in it as long as they need to, until they are ready to come back to the relationship with the adults, where exciting things can happen again.

How the adult behaves while waiting

During this process, the adult is not angry. The adult is not frustrated.

The adult is understanding and compassionate. The adult uses active listening and reflective communication to understand what the child is feeling and to help reason with the child. The adult might name what the child seems to be feeling, or say back what the child has said, so the child knows they are heard.

But it is never for the purpose of coercion. The listening is real. It is not a trick to get the child to give in.

This matters. Waiting is not a cold standoff. The adult is present, calm, and warm. The adult simply does not need to win anything, because there is no fight.

Authority without coercion

Power struggles build a history of punishing interactions between adults and children. They build a history of adversarial interactions.

Power struggles are fights. And when an adult fights with a child, the implication is that the adult and the child are equally matched.

The reality should be that the adult has all the power, and the only power the child has is what the adult allows.

That sentence can sound harsh if it is misread, so I want to be clear about what I mean.

What authority is and what it is not

When I talk about adult authority, I am talking about the adult being steady, reliable, and in charge of the environment. The adult decides what activities are offered, what the expectations are, and what is available when a child is not participating. The adult keeps promises. The adult does not get pulled into arguments.

Authority in this sense is different from punishment. It is different from physical force. It is different from humiliation, threats, or shaming. It is different from trying to control what a child thinks and feels. And it is different from authoritarian parenting, where the adult relies on harshness and demands obedience without warmth.

Research helps make this distinction clear.

Barber (1996) wrote about parental psychological control, which he describes as control that constrains, invalidates, and manipulates children's psychological and emotional experience and expression. He distinguished it from behavioral control. In his studies, psychological control, especially as perceived by preadolescents and adolescents, consistently predicted youth internalized problems such as depression, and in some cases externalized problems such as delinquency. Soenens and Vansteenkiste (2010) proposed a theoretical update of the concept of psychological control drawing on self-determination theory.

Two large meta-analyses by Pinquart point in the same direction. Across 1,015 studies, Pinquart (2016) found that parental warmth, behavioral control, autonomy granting, and authoritative parenting showed very small to small negative associations with internalizing symptoms, while harsh control, psychological control, authoritarian parenting, and in part neglectful parenting were associated with higher levels of internalizing symptoms. Across 1,435 studies, Pinquart (2017) found a similar pattern for externalizing problems. Harsh control, psychological control, authoritarian, permissive, and neglectful parenting were associated with more externalizing problems, with the strongest associations for harsh control and psychological control. Both meta-analyses also found some associations running in both directions over time, meaning children's difficulties and parents' behavior affect each other.

Kuppens and Ceulemans (2018), studying 600 Flemish families with children aged 8 to 10, found that having authoritative or positive authoritative parents was associated with the most favorable outcomes, while having authoritarian parents coincided with the least favorable outcomes. An intrusive parenting style was also associated with poorer outcomes, though less so than the authoritarian style.

These are associations. They do not prove that any one approach causes a particular outcome, and they do not test my approach directly. But they are consistent with the line I am drawing. Warmth, clear structure, and room for autonomy tend to go along with better outcomes. Harshness, manipulation, and emotional control tend to go along with worse ones.

So when I say the adult has all the power, I do not mean the adult should use it harshly. I mean the adult should never need to fight, because the adult already controls the environment and can afford to be patient and kind.

Children need freedom, not power

We do want children to have independence and agency. We want them to have opportunities for self-advocacy and choice. Those things are good, and they should grow as children grow.

But we do not want children to experience a situation at school or at home where the child has power over the adults or the other people in that environment.

Children do not need power. They need freedom and choice and independence and enjoyment and love and learning.

Power is not something children can handle over time. We might give them increasing authority over different parts of their lives as they mature. But while we are raising children and teaching children, we have authority over them. We have influence over them.

These words mean different things, and the difference matters:

  • Choice is the child deciding among options, including the option to refuse.
  • Independence is the child doing more for themselves.
  • Agency is the child acting on their own will and speaking up for themselves.
  • Authority is the adult's responsibility to set the environment and keep their word.
  • Influence is the relationship and trust that make children want to follow an adult.
  • Coercion is trying to make a child do something through force, pressure, threats, or punishment.

Children should have a lot of the first three. Adults should hold the next two firmly. And coercion has no place in the relationship.

What a power struggle tells the child

A power struggle tells the child that we have lost authority. It tells the child that we do not have the ability to control the environment.

That is a frightening message for a child, even if the child seems to be winning. A child who can push an adult into a fight learns that the adults around them are not steady. Over time, that child learns to keep pushing.

The alternative is simple, though it takes practice. Mean what you say. Keep your yes as yes and your no as no. Make the good things in the day truly good, and let them depend on the child staying with you. When a child refuses, stay calm, stay kind, listen, and say, "I can wait."

I never argue with the child. I don't need to. The child is free to choose, and I am free to wait.

References

  • Hoffman, M. L. (1960). Power Assertion by the Parent and Its Impact on the Child. Child Development. https://doi.org/10.2307/1126389
  • Bugental, D. B., & Happaney, K. (2000). Parent–Child Interaction as a Power Contest. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0193-3973(99)00038-6
  • Barber, B. K. (1996). Parental Psychological Control: Revisiting a Neglected Construct. Child Development. https://doi.org/10.2307/1131780
  • Kuppens, S., & Ceulemans, E. (2018). Parenting Styles: A Closer Look at a Well-Known Concept. Journal of Child and Family Studies. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10826-018-1242-x
  • Pinquart, M. (2016). Associations of Parenting Dimensions and Styles with Internalizing Symptoms in Children and Adolescents: A Meta-Analysis. Marriage & Family Review. https://doi.org/10.1080/01494929.2016.1247761
  • Pinquart, M. (2017). Associations of parenting dimensions and styles with externalizing problems of children and adolescents: An updated meta-analysis. Developmental Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/dev0000295
  • Soenens, B., & Vansteenkiste, M. (2010). A theoretical upgrade of the concept of parental psychological control: Proposing new insights on the basis of self-determination theory. Developmental Review. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dr.2009.11.001
  • Moed, A. (2024). An emotion-focused extension of coercion theory: Emerging evidence and conceptualizations for parental experienced emotion as a mechanism of reinforcement in coercive parent–child interactions. Child Development Perspectives. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12497
  • Scaramella, L. V., & Leve, L. D. (2004). Clarifying Parent–Child Reciprocities During Early Childhood: The Early Childhood Coercion Model. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:CCFP.0000030287.13160.a3

Copyright © 2026 Accessible Hope, LLC

Policies & Legal